Wednesday, August 25, 2010

“Women’s Health and Cancer Rights Act of 1998’’

Recently the New York signed into law requiring hospitals and doctors to discuss breast reconstruction options with the patient prior to her undergoing cancer surgery. 

It troubled me that this law was needed.  Is it not the duty of the physicians and surgeons to educate the patient on the options available? 

We need to make sure the patient and their family know of the treatment options which may vary depending on the diagnosis and stage.  Radiation.  Chemotherapy.  Surgery – lumpectomy, mastectomy, axillary dissection.  A combination of treatments.

Even if the patient and her physicians don’t chose to do immediate reconstruction, isn’t the discussion and information part of the discussion?  At least inform the patient of the option.

Do we physicians and surgeons need another law to ensure we do right by our patients?

 

Not all patient’s have health insurance so reconstruction may become unattainable due to finances.   Susan G. Komen has a nice resource page for financial assistance available for breast cancer patients.  I did not see any that would cover reconstruction.  Many will help will obtaining a prosthetic.

Patient’s that do have health insurance are afforded protection under the “Women’s Health and Cancer Rights Act of 1998.”   However, as I was reviewing and researching the WHCRC for this piece I learned that it’s not a blanket protection:

Generally, group health plans, as well as their insurance companies and HMOs, that provide coverage for medical and surgical benefits with respect to a mastectomy must comply with WHCRA.

However, if your coverage is provided by a "church plan" or "governmental plan", check with your plan administrator. Certain plans that are church plans or governmental plans may not be subject to this law.

 

 

Breast Reconstruction—Part I (October 2007)

Breast Reconstruction – Part II (October 2007)

Patient Satisfaction Following Breast Reconstruction Using Implants  (June 7, 2010)

 

 

REFERENCES

Before Breast Is Removed, a Discussion on Options; New York Times article, August 18, 2010; Anemona Hartocollis

“Women’s Health and Cancer Rights Act of 1998’’ Summary; American Society of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgeons website

Your Rights After A Mastectomy...Women's Health & Cancer Rights Act of 1998; Department of Labor

1 comment:

DrB said...

frightening, no? and yet, I can definitely attest to the fact that these doc-patient discussions are not widely accepted. I especially know this as fact from my recent interviewing throughout the US. Most hospital admins were excited to see me BECAUSE these discussions are currently amiss.