Thursday, June 25, 2009

How Poland’s Syndrome Was Named

 Updated 3/2017-- photos and all links (except to my own posts) removed as many no longer active. and it was easier than checking each one.

Poland's syndrome is a congenital disorder. The classic ipsilateral features of Poland syndrome include the following: absence of sternal head of the pectoralis major, hypoplasia and/or aplasia of breast or nipple, deficiency of subcutaneous fat and axillary hair, abnormalities of rib cage, and upper extremity anomalies. These upper extremity anomalies include short upper arm, forearm, or fingers (brachysymphalangism). (photo credit)
Additional features of Poland syndrome include the following: hypoplasia or aplasia of serratus, external oblique, pectoralis minor, latissimus dorsi, infraspinatus, and supraspinatus muscles; total absence of anterolateral ribs and herniation of lung; and symphalangism with syndactyly and hypoplasia or aplasia of the middle phalanges. (photo credit)
The name of this condition pays homage to Dr. Alfred Poland of Guy's Hospital, who in 1841 described a case of these two deformities during the autopsy of a 27-year-old convict, but as this article points out he wasn’t the first to recognize the syndrome.
If you enjoy medical history, then you will enjoy this article. It explores the historical literature to reveal the progression of knowledge about this syndrome. Here is a quick summary of different investigators who contributed to the understanding of Poland's syndrome. The article goes into more detail of each.
1826 Lallemand is first to describe the absence of the pectoralis.
1835 Bell is the first to record the absence of the pectoralis
1839 Forlep is first to describe the paired absence of the pectoralis and ipsilateral syndactyly
1841 Poland is the second to describe the paired absence of the pectoralis and ipsilateral syndactyly
1895 Thomson is the first to document an understanding that the deformities accompanied one another
1900 Furst is the first to propose that the anomalies constituted a syndrome
1902 Bing is the first to present a case series of patients with the syndrome
1940 Brown and McDowell are the first to document a thorough review of the syndrome
1962 Clarkson is the first to propose the name “Poland’s Syndactyly” for the syndrome
As the authors conclude:
Honoring physicians for notable achievements in the form of eponyms can be viewed as a harmless way to bring a little bit of warmth to an otherwise cold world of facts. The least we can do, though, is to recognize the contributions of those who endeavored to shape our current understanding of disease.
Perhaps if history took another course, Poland's syndrome would instead be called Frolep's syndrome or Furst's syndrome. Or perhaps it might simply have been called pectoral-aplasia-dysdactylia syndrome
Poland's Syndrome: Current Thoughts in the Setting of a Controversy; Plastic & Reconstructive Surgery. 123(3):949-953, March 2009; Ram, Ashwin N. B.S.; Chung, Kevin C. M.D., M.S. (subscription required)

1 comment:

Tele Jane said...

A good thing to know...
Poland syndrome!

wud neva hv known otherwise !